Hawthorne and Melville
by Jana L. Argersinger · 2008
Genre: Fiction
Rating: 4.2/5
Jana L. Argersinger's 'Hawthorne and Melville' intricately examines the complex friendship between two literary titans. A richly detailed narrative that marries biography with literary analysis.
Argersinger intricately intertwines the lives of two literary giants.
Jana L. Argersinger's 'Hawthorne and Melville' is a nuanced exploration of the complex relationship between Nathaniel Hawthorne and Herman Melville. With a lyrical yet analytical prose style, Argersinger delves into the interplay of admiration, influence, and personal turmoil that defined their bond. Her narrative is both scholarly and accessible, making it a significant contribution to literary studies.
In 'Hawthorne and Melville', Jana L. Argersinger does not merely recount the biographical details of these two towering figures of American literature; she breathes life into their storied friendship and intellectual camaraderie. Through her meticulously crafted narrative, the reader is invited to witness the ebb and flow of their relationship—a dance of intellects, if you will. Argersinger's prose is rich with detail, her insights carefully grounded in historical context, and her analysis is as precise as it is empathetic.
The book is structured around the correspondence and literary exchanges that punctuated the lives of Hawthorne and Melville. Argersinger deftly uses these letters and writings as a lens through which to explore the nuances of their friendship. The author proposes that their relationship was not solely defined by mutual admiration and artistic influence but also marked by moments of tension and divergence. This interplay of harmony and discord is captured with an elegance that engages the reader's curiosity and empathy.
Argersinger's work is as much an exploration of the authors' psychologies as it is of their crafts. She delves deeply into how each writer's personal struggles—Melville's brooding introspection and Hawthorne's reticent elegance—shaped their narratives and, by extension, American literature as a whole. The book presents a dual portrait not just of these men's artistic endeavors, but of their humanity, their flaws, and their enduring legacies.
However, the book is not without its shortcomings. At times, Argersinger's exhaustive detail on the minutiae of their correspondence can obscure the broader strokes of narrative momentum. The reader may find themselves momentarily overwhelmed by the density of information—an abundance that occasionally detracts from the thematic clarity of the work. While the depth of research is commendable, it might have benefitted from a more selective approach to highlight the most crucial interactions and influences.
Despite this, 'Hawthorne and Melville' remains a compelling read for anyone interested in the intersection of biography and literary criticism. Argersinger has constructed a framework that not only illuminates the personal dynamics between two of America's literary luminaries but also sheds light on the broader cultural and historical contexts in which they wrote. It is a scholarly achievement that will likely inspire further inquiry and appreciation of both authors' works.
Key Takeaways
- Literary friendship
- Artistic influence
- Personal struggles
Summary
- Explores the friendship between Nathaniel Hawthorne and Herman Melville.
- Uses letters and writings to delve into their intellectual camaraderie.
- Blends biographical detail with literary analysis.
- Captures the personal and artistic struggles that influenced their works.
- Occasionally overwhelms with exhaustive detail on their correspondence.
- Balances scholarly rigor with accessible prose.
- Sheds light on broader cultural and historical contexts.
- Significant contribution to literary studies, especially American literature.
Chapter Guide
- Chapter 1: Introduction: Writing a Relationship
- Jana L. Argersinger and Leland S. Person outline the known biographical facts of Hawthorne and Melville's sixteen-month friendship in 1850, emphasizing their intense correspondence and meetings in the Berkshires. They survey existing scholarship on their mutual influence, highlighting gaps in queer, globalist, and ideological readings. The chapter previews the volume's essays, framing ambiguities in their personal and literary exchanges as central to reinterpretation.
- Chapter 2: Biographical Contexts of 1850 Encounter
- This essay reconstructs the timeline of Hawthorne and Melville's meetings, from Melville's review 'Hawthorne and His Mosses' to their shared hikes and letters. It details Melville's gift of an inscribed Moby-Dick to Hawthorne, underscoring the personal stakes in their professional admiration. Archival evidence reveals how their interactions shaped immediate creative outputs.
- Chapter 3: Queer Dimensions in Their Friendship
- Applying queer theory, the authors explore homoerotic undertones in Melville's mosses essay and Hawthorne's subtle responses, portraying their bond as a 'grand hooded phantom.' Letters and metaphors suggest unspoken desires amid Victorian constraints. The essay argues this dynamic infused their fiction with veiled intensities.
- Chapter 4: Hawthorne's Influence on Moby-Dick
- Melville's exposure to The Scarlet Letter and Hawthorne's romances prompted structural innovations in Moby-Dick, particularly its meditative digressions. The chapter analyzes parallels in their treatments of guilt and obsession—Ahab echoing Dimmesdale's inner torment. It posits Hawthorne as a catalyst for Melville's encyclopedic ambitions.
- Chapter 5: Melville's Shadow in Pierre and Beyond
- Hawthorne's later works reflect Melvillean darkness, with Pierre's domestic upheavals mirroring Hawthorne's ambivalences toward family and fame. The essay traces Melville's impact on Hawthorne's shift toward irony and ambiguity in The Blithedale Romance. Mutual borrowings reveal a dialogic exchange beyond direct influence.
Read the full review at https://reviewerinsight.com/book/69ed3a79a9832dc782100af1/hawthorne-and-melville