Her Body and Other Parties
by Carmen Maria Machado · 2017
Genre: Fiction
Rating: 4.2/5
Carmen Maria Machado's debut collection hauntingly dissects the female body through speculative lenses of horror and desire. Eight stories of invention and fury that redefine feminist short fiction.
Carmen Maria Machado's debut collection redefines the short story form through bodies that haunt, hunger, and dissolve under the weight of feminine experience.
Her Body and Other Parties stands as a major debut in speculative feminist fiction; Machado's eight stories pulse with invention, blending horror, eroticism, and grief into forms that resist easy categorization. While not every tale achieves equal resonance, the collection's formal daring and unflinching gaze at women's corporeal lives mark it as essential reading. I recommend it to those who seek prose that interrogates the body not as metaphor, but as battleground.
Machado's collection opens with 'The Husband Stitch,' a tale that weaves fairy-tale ribbon into the gritty realism of heterosexual marriage; here, the green ribbon at the narrator's throat—binding her untold secret—serves as both literal and symbolic restraint, a nod to '80s urban legends recast through the lens of gendered violence. This story sets the tonal template: bodies marked by desire and danger, where pleasure curdles into peril. What elevates Machado's approach is her structural play; she folds folklore into contemporary unease, allowing the supernatural to emerge not as escape, but as amplification of the everyday horrors women endure—catcalls morphing into hauntings, intimacy into invasion. The prose hums with sensory precision, erotic without sensationalism; lovers' skin 'tastes of salt and meat,' a phrase that lingers like a bruise.
In 'Inventory,' Machado departs from narrative convention altogether, listing lovers in a staccato catalogue that builds from casual flings to apocalyptic voids; each entry accrues lovers' traits—'a girl who collects snowglobes,' 'a man who smells of gasoline'—until the litany fractures under implied catastrophe, perhaps plague or personal unraveling. This formal experiment, reminiscent of Jenny Offill's fragmented novels yet fiercer in its queer eroticism, interrogates memory's unreliability and the body's tally of losses. 'Especially Heinous,' meanwhile, reimagines Law & Order: SVU episodes as surreal dispatches from a dystopian New York, where twin detectives stalk phantom crimes amid 'ghost women' dissolving into walls—a brilliant parody that skewers true-crime voyeurism while mourning erased femininity.
Machado's voice shifts nimbly across stories; 'Mothers' plunges into a post-flu maternity ward where new parents confront feral infants and their own monstrous instincts, its stream-of-consciousness epistolary form mimicking exhaustion's haze. 'The Resident' traps a writer in a retreat where residents' bodies shrink daily, fat folding into nothingness—a grotesque metaphor for self-erasure under scrutiny. These pieces thrive on what the novel *does*: they hybridize genres, quilting sci-fi, fairy tale, and horror into feminist tapestries that expose patriarchy's corporeal toll. Machado quotes sparingly but potently; in 'Eight Bites,' the line 'Her body was no longer her own; it was a public resource' captures the collection's core fury.
Yet for all its brilliance, the collection falters in consistency; 'Rentas,' with its parallel epidemics of illness and club music's infectious beat, strains under its own conceits—the dual plagues feel schematically mirrored, diluting emotional punch amid rhythmic repetition that borders on gimmickry. This story, ambitious in form, reveals Machado's occasional overreliance on bodily metamorphosis as shorthand for trauma; the specificity of horror blurs into abstraction, leaving readers grasping for firmer ground. While the other tales ground their weirdness in lived intimacy, 'Rentas' drifts toward allegory, a weakness amid such otherwise precise architecture. Even here, though, Machado's language seduces—'the bass entered their bodies like a second bloodstream'—reminding us of her prodigious gifts.
Her Body and Other Parties arrives as a debut that announces a singular talent; Machado, who would later refine her powers in the memoir In the Dream House, here pioneers a queer speculative feminism that influences a generation of writers. The collection demands rereading, its structures rewarding close scrutiny—em-dashes punctuating revelations, semicolons linking bodily states. It is not flawless, but its flaws are the risks of audacity; in a literary landscape wary of the weird, Machado insists on bodies as sites of both ecstasy and annihilation. This is fiction that sticks to the ribs.
Key Takeaways
- Corporeal Horror
- Feminist Autonomy
- Queer Eroticism
Summary
- Eight interconnected stories explore women's bodies under siege from desire, violence, and societal judgment.
- 'The Husband Stitch' reimagines urban legends as marital horror, centering the green ribbon's deadly secret.
- 'Inventory' lists lovers in fragmented prose, building to unspoken apocalypse.
- Blends horror, sci-fi, and fairy tale with queer eroticism and feminist rage.
- 'Especially Heinous' parodies true-crime TV in a city of vanishing ghost women.
- Formal innovations—like epistolary exhaustion in 'Mothers'—mirror thematic bodily dissolutions.
- Reservation: 'Rentas' overreaches with schematic dual plagues, tipping into abstraction.
- Verdict: A formally daring debut that recommends itself unreservedly to speculative fiction readers.
Chapter Guide
- Chapter 1: The Husband Stitch
- A woman recounts the strange, often unsettling, experiences of her marriage, centered on a mysterious green ribbon her husband is forbidden to untie. This story explores the boundaries of intimacy and the secrets held within relationships.
- Chapter 2: Inventory
- As a plague sweeps the land, a woman chronicles her sexual encounters and relationships, detailing each partner and the circumstances of their meeting. It becomes a poignant record of connection and survival in a world unraveling.
- Chapter 3: Mothers, Lock Up Your Daughters Because They Are Terrifying
- A group of teenage girls at a reform school exhibit strange, unsettling behaviors, hinting at a supernatural transformation and a collective, unsettling power. The narrative explores the monstrous feminine and societal fear of female agency.
- Chapter 4: Especially Heinous: 27 True Cases of the SVU
- This story reimagines episodes of 'Law & Order: SVU' through a surreal, often grotesque, lens, blurring the lines between reality and television. It critiques the consumption of violence and the commodification of trauma.
- Chapter 5: Eight Bites
- A woman undergoes bariatric surgery, leading to unexpected, almost supernatural, consequences as parts of her former self manifest. The narrative explores body image, self-transformation, and the lingering echoes of past identities.
Read the full review at https://reviewerinsight.com/book/69ed4fa9f2f1713bdeb2c6a7/her-body-and-other-parties